P>It has been a little over a year since Gov. Gary Locke met with the
tribes at the Sleeping Lady Resort in Leavenworth, where three
November days of detailed discussion culminated with the signing of the
“New Millenium Agreement.”
I remember thinking how appropriate it was for all of this to take
place at this beautiful location, at the foot of
the namesake mountain. Here, the “Sleeping Lady” has borne
witness to all that has transpired between the Indian and
non-Indian people for centuries.
I imagined at the time that a Millenium Agreement
might just awaken the lady, who could bear witness to long-awaited better times
for our people. After all, one might assume that a Millenium Agreement
is one that’s intended to last a thousand years. But, unfortunately, this one
appears to be on track to fall well short of that mark. It seems the
Sleeping Lady may have stirred and stretched for a moment, but then returned to
her ageless slumber.
The Millenium Agreement was intended to be an agreement to
“institutionalize” the state/tribal
government-to-government relationship in preparation for the new millenium.
To achieve this, the governor and other state officials swore to make the
principles of the 1989 Centennial Accord come alive in our day-to-day
relations. Tribal officials concurred. The principles ranged from high-level
collaboration in economic, social/cultural and natural resources-related issues, to
improved communication, cooperative education and the development of
a consensus-based, lasting and respectful relationship between the state
and the tribes. That may seem like a tall order, but these are the things that
are needed if we’re ever going to make real progress in state/tribal relations.
In signing the agreement, the governor said, “In our centennial year
of 1989, the tribes and the state signed the Centennial Accord, reaffirming
the that we must work together, government-to-government, for the benefit
of both tribal and non-tribal people. A decade later we sign this
New Millenium Agreement to emphasize the importance of making the
Centennial Accord a part of our everyday lives. The economic, cultural,
environmental and leadership contributions of the tribes to this state are far
greater than most people realize. I call on all citizens of the state to support
this agreement and commit themselves to improved tribal/non-tribal
understanding and relations.”
The words sounded great, but in the year since there has been very
little follow-up and virtually no progress in state/tribal collaboration. Little
wonder that there’s been little overall progress for tribes.
In the economic arena, the state-sanctioned Tiller Report,
“Economic Contributions of Indian Tribes to
the Economy of Washington State,” concluded that the tribes contribute
$1 billion annually to the state’s overall economy, yet the tribes receive a
tiny fraction of this investment back in the form of state support and
services. Tribal wage earners receive 40 percent less than the statewide average,
for example. Across the board, tribal members’ education and
employment opportunities lag far behind the norm. The same goes for investments in
such things as emergency services, roads and other infrastructure on
reservations.
In the social/cultural arena, the story is the same. The tribes
continue to face constant challenges in their efforts to protect their cultural
values. People and machines wreak havoc on our sacred sites. Education about
our long-term history and contemporary programs continues to be
insufficient, and support for our health and welfare is a fraction of that invested
in Americans.
In the natural resources arena, the Millenium Agreement called for
state officials to “work toward the resolution of differences of
geographic scope, pursue joint/tribal agreement on management areas and clarify
access to private timber lands.” In the long term, actions were to include the
development of a resource management plan, a long-term hunting agreement
and legislative strategy. None of these things have materialized.
In salmon management, the governor’s “Extinction Is Not An
Option” plan continues to be inadequate by any measure. There is no
meaningful provision for state/tribal collaboration in this plan. The
“voluntary compliance” it advocates may
sound good to business and agricultural interests, but it fails to provide for
any meaningful protection of salmon habitat or other treaty-protected
natural resource management rights.
A year ago, the governor said, “In the long run, the value of
this Millenium Agreement will be measured in terms of how well the
people and the governments of this state, Indian and non-Indian, work
together, learn together and cooperate. We are committed to help make this happen.”
The Sleeping Lady stirred, as did our collective spirit. But the
words, like so many before, soon fell lifeless to the ground.
We hope the governor’s recent re-election will breathe new life into
his commitment and that he will work with us to develop a positive,
collaborative relationship. We hope he will work with us to fully awaken
the Sleeping Lady.
Billy Frank Jr. is chairman of the Northwest Indian Fisheries
Commission.